Epistemology was a latecomer to feminist analysis and critique. Feminist epistemology philosophy oxford bibliographies. Elizabeth anderson university of michigan academia. An interpretation and defense, hypatia, 1995, 10, 3, 5084. Feminist epistemology and philosophy of science, elizabeth anderson first published wed aug 9, 2000. Aug 09, 2000 outside critics of feminist epistemology have argued that the entire research program is fundamentally flawed. But feminist epistemology is better understood as the branch of. I shall call empiricism the view that experience ultimately provides all the evidence we have about the world reference nelson nelson 1990, or more modestly, that observation provides the least defeasible evidence we have about the world reference longino longino 1993a. Justification of theories should be value free, haack. Pdf situating feminist epistemology robin mckenna and. Democratic epistemology, social epistemology and womens.
Feminist standpoint epistemology is a unique philosophy of knowledge building that challenges us to 1 see and understand the world through the. While demonstrating very strong critical orientation, feminist epistemology seriously takes constructive efforts further. Here we are concerned with claims to know, temporarily bracketing the question of which claims are true or warranted. For instance, feminist epistemologists suggest that various kinds of practical knowhow and personal knowledge knowledge that bears the marks. Feminist epistemology conceives of knowers as situated in particular relations to what is known and to other knowers. Lather, 1991 rejects all grand narratives, including feminist grand theory explanations of womens condition and oppression. Feminist standpoint epistemology starts from the assumption that knowledge is socially constructed and rejects the positivist notion of objectivity.
How should a critique that purports to decisively undermine an entire field of inquiry be evaluated. Feminist epistemology has often been understood as the study of feminine ways of knowing. Feminist epistemology essay example free essays online. But feminist epistemology is better understood as the branch of naturalized, social epistemology that studies the various influences of norms and conceptions of gender and gendered interests and experiences on the production of knowledge. Feminist philosophy of science in philosophy of science, misc categorize this paper reprint years 1993, 20, 2015. Apr 10, 2018 we argue that some versions of two of the main strands in feminist epistemology feminist standpoint theory and feminist empiricism are committed to a form of social constructivism, which requires certain departures from traditional epistemological thinking. All postslavery societies, including haiti, jamaica, and the u. Feminist epistemology and the search for liberating knowledge. Feminist epistemology and philosophy of science research.
An interpretation and a defense is sure to become a definitive piece. Feminism and science, the american scholar, 57 1988, 100 106. But feminist epistemology is better understood as the branch of naturalized. Situating feminist epistemology episteme cambridge core. Guest speaker loretta kensinger on feminist pedagogy 118. Sally haslanger, what knowledge is and what it ought to be. Feminist epistemology internet encyclopedia of philosophy. First, empiricist epistemology is based on the utopian ideal of objective inquiry that, in fact and in principle, impedes scientific progress. In the second section we will look at feminist areas in philosophy such as feminist epistemology and feminist ethics in order to identify how feminism has contributed to the. Feminist epistemology comprises of diverse and not always compatible each other, dynamic and far from complete theoretical projects nelson 1995. Here are some items that may be useful to focus on feel free to select others. Feminist social epistemology stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Feminist philosophy comprehensive western university.
Feminist methodologies and epistemology research paper. The recent turn toward experimental philosophy, particularly in ethics and epistemology, might appear to be supported by feminist epistemology, insofar as experimental philosophy signifies a break from the tradition of primarily white, middleclass men attempting to draw universal claims from within the limits of their own experience and research. Thus, science cannot and should not strive to live up to the stated standards of empiricist epistemology, and feminist standpoint theorists reject the notion of disinterested, value free. Sandra burt and lorraine code broadview press 1995. The abolition of slavery offers a case study in pragmatist methods. Feminist epistemology is an examination of epistemology the study of knowledge from a. A general problem with mainstream epistemology and philosophy of science from feminist perspectives is that the well accepted concept of knowledge and scientific practices derived from it deny the impacts of social and political dimension toward knowing activities and their results. Feminist standpoint epistemologies posit womens difference as a resource for. Helen elizabeth longino born july, 1944 is an american philosopher of science who has argued for the significance of values and social interactions to scientific inquiry. The article explores neomaterialist feminist theories in a number of areas, with special emphasis on science and technology studies and critiques of globalisation.
Scientists of feminist epistemology claim that knowledge discriminate 1 women by. We may con clude, then, that contextual values are not necess. Feminist social epistemology stanford encyclopedia of. She is the clarence irving lewis professor of philosophy at stanford university. Feminist ontologies, epistemologies, methodologies, and.
However, a new feminist epistemology of feminist postmodernism, apparently rejecting foundationalism in all its forms, is being constituted. I note on 5 october that those before the subsection paradoxes have been corrected. This feminist postmodernist epistemology eg, weedon, 1987. Download file to see previous pages feminist epistemology questions the posting of individual as the ultimate vehicle of knowledge, the objectivitysubjectivity dualism, the ideal of abstract universal knowledge, imparting more comparative value to the context of justification over the context of discovery, and viewing science as the ultimate paradigm yi kang, 2009, p. The potential of emotions in feminist epistemology. What implications does feminism have for epistemology what counts as knowledgeignorance. Feminist postmodernism argues that there can be no truth outside the social transformation 30 1996 65. Scrutinizing feminist epistemology, edited by cassandra pinnick, noretta koertge, and robert almeder 2003, henceforth, sfe offers a systematic critique of feminist epistemology. But we argue that these departures are less problematic than one might think.
Feminist epistemology is not the study or defense of feminine intuitions, of womens ways of knowing, of subjectivism. While potentially a limited set of categories, postmodern feminism was a transitional ideology that denounced absolute objectivity and asserted the death of the metanarrative. Feminist epistemology is about the ways gender influences what we take to. Perspectives from a nonwestern feminist, in susan bordo and alison jaggar eds.
Equal opportunity surely means that women should be free to pursue any specialty they wish within philosophy, and it is with regard to the broader inclusion of women in the discipline overall that the report is more troubling. Contextualism in feminist epistemology and philosophy of science. This book offers a distinctive and original approach to the field. Feminist epistemology conceives of knowers as situated in particular relations to what is. Essays in feminist education, supra note 12, at 248, 25253. Reflecting the dominant trend in analytic philosophy generally, epistemology is discussed nearly to the exclusion of metaphysics, and these analytic feminists favor naturalized and socialized epistemology.
Haslanger has suggested an interpretation of mackinnon which offer. Traditional epistemology finds these claims of feminist epistemology to be highly disturbing, if not plainly absurd. Developing jaggars account by tina strasbourg university of calgary abstract in this paper i analyze the potential of allison jaggars suggestion that emotions in general, and outlaw emotions in particular, be incorporated into feminist epistemology. This alternative seems to fit code though, in this case, appearances are deceiving. Feminist standpoint epistemology has been criticized for implying there is an essential woman collins 2000, for giving epistemic pri vile ge to gender oppres. An early defense of the view that feminist epistemology should be naturalized. Free agency and selfworth, journal of philosophy 9112. The resultant knowledge will not be aperspectival and will. Feminist standpoint epistemologies within the natural. Leibniz, preface to the new essays on human understanding. Feminist epistemology would be epistemology aware of its own feminist implications. Feminist epistemology and the search for liberating.
Each individual might be subject to perhaps ineradicable cognitive biases or partiality due to. Sandra harding organized feminist epistemology into three categories. Critical and constructive dimensions of feminist epistemology. Critical characteristic uncovers various forms of masculine tendencies at. Phil 376 philosophy and feminism winter 2019 instructor. Furthermore, jaggar claims that feminist outlaw emotionswhich are outlaw emotions that incorporate feminist perceptions and valuesare particularly useful in feminist epistemology because they can help in developing alternatives to prevailing reality by motivating new investigations feminist emotions provide a political. Feminist epistemology and philosophy of science, elizabeth. Her principal area of research is feminist epistemology and. Feminist epistemology and philosophy of science stanford.
We will then argue that, as with standpoint theory, some versions of feminist empiricism hold that justification depends on social factors in both constitutive and causal senses, whereas others may be better interpreted as. My interpretation is based on the writings of feminists such as nancy hartsock the feminist standpoint. Feminist epistemology and the politics of knowledge. Feminist empiricismwe will start by introducing feminist empiricism as a version of naturalised epistemology 3. It aims to show that the entire enterprise is a failure. When all affected parties can participate in the construction and interpretation of experiments in living, systematic moral biases are more likely to be corrected. Feminist values and normative epistemology iii empiricism and a priori knowledge john locke, an essay concerning human understanding, 1. Feminism operates on various feminist epistemologies, methodologies, and methods. Leading critiques of feminist epistemology include a collection of essays in the monist, 774 1994, gross and levitt 1994, haack 1993, and pinnick, koertge and almeder 2003. Feminist theory and education, in learning our way.
Feminist epistemology conceives of knowers as situated in particular. What is known, and the way that it is known, thereby reflects the situation or perspective of the knower. I am not claiming here evidence that the report is biased. Some feminist epistemologists in turn have rejected empiricism harding 1986 or even traditional epistemology as a whole flax 1983 for its seeming inability to comprehend these claims. Critical ethnography, however, occupies a position somewhere between realism and idealism san roman 2009, in that it rejects the idea that knowledge production can be value free. Feminist epistemology as of 4 october 2018 i found the following errors and weaknesses. Classifying these epistemologies generally under the umbrella or in the constellation of postpositivism makes. Elizabeth anderson characterizes feminist epistemology as properly belonging. Although various explanations for its tardiness might be advanced, central among them must surely be the intransigence of a conviction that, while ethics and politics might well be shaped by gender relations and other human differences, knowledge worthy of the. The first is that critiques of feminist epistemology offered by feminist theorists and mainstream epistemologists have relied on questionable views of both epistemology and feminist epistemology.
619 1149 402 415 259 1394 643 1005 997 1094 579 935 26 913 1125 611 1079 506 269 713 1474 636 1419 1361 110 705 688 950 563 435 605 210 1 534 1497 1492